Skip to main content

Barbados - Margaret Wharton vs. the Bank of Nova Scotia - Constructive dismissal Case

Constructive Dismissal

Constructive dismissal refers to a situation in which an employee resigns from their job due to a fundamental breach of their employment contract by the employer. This breach may involve actions, omissions, or changes in the employment terms and conditions that are so significant that they effectively make it impossible for the employee to continue working in their current role. Constructive dismissal is often considered a last resort when an employee believes they have no other option but to resign due to intolerable working conditions.

For a claim of constructive dismissal to be valid in Barbados or a country like the UK, certain conditions must generally be met:

Fundamental Breach of Contract: The employer must have committed a serious breach of the employment contract, such as a significant change in job duties, a unilateral reduction in pay, harassment, or a failure to provide a safe working environment.

Employee Resignation: The employee must resign from their job in response to the employer's breach. It is crucial that the employee makes it clear that they are resigning due to the employer's actions or omissions.

Reasonable Response: The employee's decision to resign must be a reasonable response to the employer's breach. If an employee continues to work without protesting or raises their concerns without resigning, they may be considered to have accepted the changes or conditions.

Exhaustion of Internal Procedures: In many cases, the employee is expected to have exhausted internal grievance procedures and tried to resolve the issue with the employer before resigning. Failing to do so may affect the employee's claim.

Timeliness: The resignation should occur promptly after the breach, and the employee should not continue working for an extended period under the unacceptable conditions.

If an employee successfully claims constructive dismissal, they are effectively treated as having been unfairly dismissed by their employer. They may be entitled to various remedies, including compensation for wrongful dismissal and possibly unfair dismissal, depending on the circumstances.

Employees considering constructive dismissal should seek legal advice and may want to explore other avenues, such as raising grievances or seeking mediation, before making the difficult decision to resign. Constructive dismissal cases can be complex and challenging to prove, so it is essential to gather evidence and follow proper procedures when pursuing such claims.

Margaret Wharton vs Bank of Nova Scotia

In case No. 438 of 2005, Margaret Wharton (the plaintiff) brought a constructive dismissal lawsuit against the Bank of Nova Scotia (the defendant). Wharton had been with the bank since 1976 and held various roles, including her final position as District Relationship Officer (DRO). She claimed $81,875.78 in damages for constructive dismissal, along with damages for mental, psychological, and physical injury, interest, and costs. Wharton alleged that after her 2004 promotion, she faced harassment from employees, leading to her constructive dismissal.

The bank denied dismissal, arguing that Wharton left voluntarily and disputed her alleged injuries, losses, and debts. During the trial, Wharton presented testimony and witnesses to support her claims. She eventually resigned after being offered an unsatisfactory role at the bank, citing the hostile work environment caused by harassment as the reason.

The court examined whether there was a breach of the employment contract, resulting in constructive dismissal, and if Wharton was entitled to damages. The plaintiff claimed constructive dismissal due to the defendant's alleged breaches, particularly by Mr. Bowen and Mr. Kinch. The plaintiff's counsel argued that the conduct constituted a fundamental breach of the employment contract, justifying constructive dismissal. The defendant's counsel contended that the plaintiff hadn't proven trust and confidence destruction and that failing to report misconduct hindered the defendant's investigation.

The court found the defendant's employees had engaged in inappropriate behavior, including sexual harassment, abusive language, and accusations of theft, constituting a fundamental breach of the employment contract leading to constructive dismissal. Damages awarded included $56,842.50 as severance pay and $16,235.37 as salary in lieu of notice, totaling $65,640.41, plus 6% interest from the writ filing date. Costs were also awarded to be taxed or agreed upon.

In summary, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiff, concluding she had been constructively dismissed due to the defendant's breaches and awarded her damages accordingly.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Employee Goes Berserk and Explodes at the Rubis Coverley Service Station Pump in Barbados: Was This a Preventable Workplace Breakdown?

Image
A Workplace Commentary on the Rubis Coverley Incident By  Peter MacD Earle BSc, LLM, Employment Law Consultant On Friday, May 17, 2025, Barbadians awoke to disturbing news involving the aftermath of a workplace conflict that escalated dramatically. Daniel Arnold Vincent Belle, 38, a former employee of the Rubis Coverley gas station in Christ Church, appeared in the District “B” Magistrates’ Court and admitted to causing extensive damage to the station—an estimated $7,000 worth—just days after his dismissal from the company. The incident involved the smashing of a glass door, breaking two windows, damaging a display unit, and tearing off seven fuel pump nozzles. Surveillance footage led to Belle’s arrest in Oistins. While this act of destruction was clearly criminal, the context in which it occurred raises serious concerns about workplace conflict, employer responsibilities, and the role of mental health in employment relations. . Let me be clear from the outset: I do not have any a...
Read more

Barbados' Minimum Wage Time Bomb: Are Businesses Being Set Up to Fail?

Image
   Peter MacD Earle BSc, LLM Employment Law Leicester De Montfort Law School Effective June 1, 2025, Barbados will implement a new minimum wage of $420 per week, a 23.5% increase from the current $340. In addition, legislation proposes an automatic 2% annual wage increase starting in January 2026. But beneath this progressive façade lies a stark, structural truth: Barbados has neither the machinery to enforce the law nor the political will to protect the most vulnerable. While this policy signals social justice on paper, in practice it could collapse under its own contradictions—and set workers, employers, and the economy up for failure. ________________________________________ The Illusion of Legal Protection While the government trumpets the wage hike as a win for working-class families, Barbados remains woefully unequipped to enforce the new standard. Consider: • Thousands of workers never received the current $340 minimum wage. • Many will not receive the new $420 rate...
Read more

Former BWA Boss in Barbados Fired from WASA After $13.4M Plan Collapses

Image
  By Peter MacD Earle BSc. LLM | Employment Law Consultant | June 2025 From BWA to WASA: The Rise and Fall of Keithroy Halliday St. Kitts-born Keithroy Halliday was appointed General Manager of the Barbados Water Authority (BWA) on February 15, 2017, bringing a strong track record in strategic leadership and regional public sector reform. Over the next seven years, he would become a defining figure in the BWA’s modernization efforts—managing national emergencies such as the South Coast sewage crisis and spearheading an island-wide mains replacement initiative. By 2020, Halliday had risen to Acting Chief Executive Officer, a role he held during a period of deep organizational restructuring. His resignation in August 2024 marked the end of a significant chapter in the BWA’s evolution—and the beginning of a controversial new role abroad as CEO of Trinidad and Tobago’s Water and Sewerage Authority (WASA), from which he would be abruptly dismissed less than a year later amid sweeping po...
Read more